Ahoy, mateys! Ever find yourself staring at your pirate in Sea of Thieves and thinking, "This just isn't me anymore"? Maybe you got a little too click-happy during the initial character creation, or perhaps the sea air has you craving a whole new vibe. Well, guess what? In 2026, giving your pirate a complete identity overhaul is not only possible but surprisingly straightforward. No need to abandon your hard-earned loot and reputation either—this guide walks you through the magical world of the Pirate Appearance Potion, your ticket to a fresh start without losing a single gold coin of progress. Let's dive in and get you that perfect new look!

The Big Question: Cosmetic Swap vs. Full Character Reboot

First things first, let's clear the deck on what you're actually changing. Since launch, Sea of Thieves has always let you tweak the fun stuff—your hair, makeup, outfits—by buying cool cosmetics with your in-game gold. That's like putting on a fancy new hat! But sometimes, you need more than a hat. You need a whole new you.

That's where the real character change comes in. We're talking about the foundational stuff:

  • Body type

  • Gender presentation

  • Skin tone

  • Facial features (the nose knows!)

Think of it this way: cosmetics are your wardrobe; changing your character is getting a whole new skeleton. A pirate's gotta do what a pirate's gotta do, right? Gotta keep the Royal Navy guessing!

pirate-makeover-guide-how-to-completely-change-your-character-in-sea-of-thieves-2026-edition-image-0

Your Step-by-Step Voyage to a New You

Ready to set sail for a new face? Follow this treasure map. It's easier than navigating a storm with a broken compass!

1. Chart Your Course: Load the Main Menu

Boot up Sea of Thieves and sail right past the option to choose your Adventure or Arena Mode. You want the main menu, the calm harbor before the storm. This is your launching point.

pirate-makeover-guide-how-to-completely-change-your-character-in-sea-of-thieves-2026-edition-image-1

2. Dock at the Pirate Emporium

Spot that shiny box in the upper right corner labeled "Pirate Emporium"? That's your destination. Click it! This is the in-game store where you can buy all sorts of swag for your ship, your pet parrot, and, most importantly, your pirate self.

3. Find the 'Pirate' Tab & The Magic Potion

Once inside the Emporium, you'll see a row of tabs at the top. Navigate over to the "Pirate" tab. Here, amidst the flashy weapon skins and hilarious emotes, lies your prize: the Pirate Appearance Potion. It's usually hanging out right in the center-bottom of the screen, just waiting for you.

pirate-makeover-guide-how-to-completely-change-your-character-in-sea-of-thieves-2026-edition-image-2

The Cost of Transformation: Ancient Coins

Alright, let's talk doubloons. The potion isn't free—it costs 149 Ancient Coins. In real-world money, that's roughly:

  • $2.09 USD

  • $2.69 CAD

Not too shabby for a whole new life on the seas! If your coin purse is feeling light, you can buy more Ancient Coins directly. Just click the '+' icon usually found in the bottom-right corner of the Emporium screen. Pro tip: keep an eye out for sales or in-game events where you can hunt Ancient Skeletons to earn coins for free!

Here’s the full breakdown of coin packages available in 2026 (Game Pass owners still get that sweet discount!):

Ancient Coins Cost (USD) Cost with Game Pass (USD) Cost (CAD) Cost with Game Pass (CAD)
150 $1.99 $1.79 $2.49 $2.24
550 $5.99 $5.39 $7.69 $6.92
1,000 $9.99 $8.99 $12.79 $11.51
2,550 $22.99 $20.69 $29.99 $26.99
4,250 $34.99 $31.49 $44.99 $40.49

The Grand Finale: Choosing Your New Pirate

You've bought the potion! Now for the fun part. You need to completely close and restart Sea of Thieves. Once you relaunch the game, the magic happens. You won't go to the usual menu. Instead, you'll be whisked away...

...to the bottom of the ship.

pirate-makeover-guide-how-to-completely-change-your-character-in-sea-of-thieves-2026-edition-image-3

Here, you'll be presented with a fresh batch of randomly generated pirates to choose from. This is the moment! Take your time. Scroll through. Look at every scar, every glint in the eye.

⚠️ CRUCIAL PIRATE PRO-TIP ⚠️

Don't you dare settle for a pirate you only kinda like! You paid good coin for this. If none of the first set of pirates speak to your soul, here's the secret: close the game and reboot it again. Each time you restart after buying the potion, you'll get a brand new set of pirates to pick from. Rinse and repeat until you find The One. It's like window-shopping for a new identity—take all the time you need!

And the best part? All your progress—your reputation, your gold, your collected cosmetics—sails right into the sunset with your new look. It's a clean slate without any of the grind.

So there you have it! Changing your pirate in 2026 is a breeze. Whether you're escaping a notorious reputation or just fancied a change of scenery in the mirror, the Pirate Appearance Potion is your best first mate for the job. Now go forth, find your perfect face, and give 'em hell on the high seas! 🏴‍☠️⚓